Sunday, March 30, 2008

#281-The Death Of a Soldier


In the poem, The Death of a Soldier, by Wallace Stevens, knowing who the speaker is helps understand the meaning of the poem. The speaker is not the soldier in the poem like how many war poems are, but rather the speaker is Stevens himself. He is using an unnamed and unrecognized, fictitious soldier to relate his ideas to the audience. He is writing the poem as a way to express his opinion on war, but more importantly religion. The poem has an overall tone of sadness and finality without celebration. There are numerous works of Stevens's that challenge common idea of religion in a way that appears atheistic. It is not so much that he is writing against the idea that these things actually happened, but he sometimes criticizes the ideas of the Christian faith. Knowing that Stevens has a history of atheistic views present in his writing helps the reader understand some of the references he makes in the poem. When you first look at the physical format of the poem, it appears as if there will be a structured rhyme scheme and meter. However, upon analyzing the poem I was unable to conclude any specific form. There are few words that rhyme with any other word in the poem and the pattern of the syllables yields no formal type of meter. This free verse is very representative of the poem, though. The overall message is that the soldier is laying down his life without making a big deal about it. There is no ceremony or service. These things would imply structure. Without, the poem having a formalized structure, it shows that the soldier's death also lacked the normal, structure of death.


One interesting literary device Stevens chooses to use is repetition. In the first and third stanzas, the line "As in a season of autumn." (2 and 8) is present as the second line of the stanzas. Now at first I was challenged to figure out the meaning of the repetition, but I eventually came up with a response that may seem a little unexpected because of its simplicity. I focused on the type of season autumn is. To me, it is the ending of summer, the ending of warm weather and sunny days. It is the transition to the cold darkness of winter. In my mind, fall is the unrecognized and undistinguished season. Instead of people seeing fall as still offering some warm days, many see fall as the ushering in of winter. It is almost as if fall is blamed for being the precursor to the worst season. And you can say I'm looking too into things, but if you think about it fall is a lonely set of three months. For example, there is no major holiday or event that occurs in the fall. Now some could argue that Thanksgiving takes place, but that is only an American holiday. Around the world you have Christmas in winter, Easter in spring, and just the joy that summer is here during summer, but there is no celebration of fall. This portrays the soldier perfectly. He is just another soldier laying down his life without a big deal being made about it. This presents a sad view of the futility of war because his life is valuable, but is not being recognized. Perhaps the most important and obvious device used in the poem are the biblical allusions. Stevens writes, "He does not become a three-days personage" (4). This is a direct reference to the death of Christ. Christ died and rose again three days later. For many Christians, those three days before Easter are very solemn and filled with ceremony. This is where the atheistic tone is present in the poem. Stevens takes a shot at Christianity saying that Christ died and everyone makes a huge deal about it. He is not saying that a big deal shouldn't be made, but does not see how it is fair that the dead soldier can so easily be forgotten. Stevens argues that Christ was supposed to come and die for all of us, but it seems a bit ironic that Christ receives all the big to-do while many people he was supposed to save just die. They die alone and are not recognized. Stevens wonders where the love of the soldier's life is.


This poem was intriguing in many different aspects. Stevens is making quite a big statement in the poem. I can't agree with his views on the irony of people celebrating Christ in ceremony, but I can see his argument on behalf of the unknown soldier. Is it too much for all of us to expect some sort of recognition of our lives when we die? I don't think it is too much. It deeply saddens me that the soldier just gives up his life and does not receive any recognition. I thought Stevens has a creative message about war. He is obviously against it, but it is in a more subtle way that he expresses his feelings. He is able to delve into the religiousness (or lack thereof) of the lack of recognition for the average soldier. It was a simple poem, that held a complex message.

#209-Good Times


In the poem, Good Times, by Lucille Clifton, the speaker of the poem is tremendously important. It appears that it is a little girl relating the poem to the audience. Clifton either uses the girl to represent herself and her childhood. So in essence, the speaker of the poem is the author, she is just speaking through a created character. Knowing Clifton's background helps understand her reasons for writing the poem. She was African American and faced many financial and family hardships growing up in an age where it was hard enough on African Americans without having to worry about personal issues. In the poem, Clifton is relating personal experience to the audience. The last line shows that the poem is a message to perhaps her own children as her family may be facing hard times, and she is trying to tell them that things will get better. While structured rhyme scheme and meter are not present in this poem, the freeness and unstructuredness of it add to the overall meaning immensely. Not only is Clifton writing about difficulties in her family, but she is also rebelling against a society that has not yet accepted the equality of African Americans. By not having a structured, organized poem, Clifton is able to rebel against a society dominated by white tradition and ideals. Many consider her to be one of the great Black Aesthetic poets who focused on creating her own style of writing through unconventional structures. Another trademark of Clifton's in the poem is the lack of capitalization in places where capitalization would be expected. For example, in line 4 uncle is lower cased despite it being a title and the only lines that begin with a capital letter are the first lines of the first two stanzas. All of these aspects help make Clifton's poem very unique and personal, which support the meaning of the poem.


Lucille Clifton makes use of two simple, yet extremely effective literary devices to add to the meaning of the poem. The first one she uses is diction/syntax. The style of her writing is very colloquial, which gives the audience the sense of the poem being authentic and based on real life. She names family members using childish titles such as Daddy, Mama, and Grampaw. These names are important because it shows that the poem is a recollection of the author's. Clifton uses the little girl as the speaker to make poem appear to be in real time. If Clifton had written it as a memory, but used words like Dad, Mom, and Grandfather, the experience of reading the poem would have been lessened because it would not feel like it was coming straight from real life. She also writes using improper grammar at points to again show that the poem is from her point of view as a child. For example, she says, "they is good times" (line 7). If, instead, Clifton had wrote 'they were good times' the effectiveness of having the child speaking would have been lost. The word were would have been more matter of fact that personal. Another device utilized by Clifton in the poem is repetition. In the first two stanzas, good times is repeated three times at the end. This added emphasis is key because it shows the attempt by Clifton to reassure the reader that there are good times even though things may be difficult now. Another repeated word is kitchen in the second stanza. Generally good things happen in the kitchen. Food is made, laughs are shared, and memories are made. A kitchen is generally a joyous place and by repeating the word it just adds to the message of the poem.


On the whole, I thought Clifton's poem was a very creative piece. She tastefully relates a childhood experience while rebelling against white society that has yet to grant equality to African Americans. I enjoyed how Clifton paints the image of financial hardship by saying, "My Daddy has paid the rent/and the insurance man is gone" (1-2). I could see the scene being an inner city with Clifton's family trying to make ends meet. The poem was uplifting, though, because despite their money problems, they made the best of what they had when they had it. I also was fond of the style Clifton wrote in. The dialect and structure helped put me in the scene so I could really appreciate what Clifton was writing about. It was also great how she was using the poem as a sign of hope for good things to come during bad times, and on the larger scale perhaps equality of all people in society.

Saturday, March 29, 2008

#263-A Work of Artifice




In this poem by Marge Piercy, there is no specific speaker as the poem is told in a third person omniscient point of view. However, it is obvious that Piercy is this omniscient narrator. Many works by Piercy are about oppression of women. She is easily considered a feminist. The entire poem is a portrayal of struggles of women. The narrator relates the story of women with describing a bonsai tree being pruned so it stays small instead of growing to its full potential. Knowing the narrator has the perspective of a feminist helped the reader to understand many of the symbols used in the poem. There was no rhyme scheme or specific meter in the poem. The poem was free verse. The physical structure of the poem is important, though. Most of the lines are kept short to represent the bonsai tree and in turn women not being able to grow to their full potential. The free verse is actually used an ironic way. It is showing exactly what women cannot do; be what they want. If the poem had a structured rhyme scheme and meter, it would have added to the structured lives of what were expected in women's' lives. However, Piercy uses the free verse to represent the goal of freedom for women.


One literary device Piercy uses is diction. Many of the words she uses effect the message of the poem greatly. Perhaps the most relevant example is a word in the title-artifice. You first look at it and see the word art. This arouses beauty and picturesque images in your mind. However, the word artifice is deceiving. It in fact means dishonesty or untruthful. This is representative of the entire poem. On the surface it looks artistic with a bonsai tree as the subject of the poem. However the poem is not about bonsai trees, but women being oppressed. Because of the trickery in the superficialness of the poem. Key words such as artifice add much to the overall effectiveness of the poem. Another literary device utilized by Piercy is the use of symbols/allusions. The poem itself is one big allusion. It is telling the story of a bonsai tree, but is symbolic of women's' struggle for equality. The last five lines of the poem contain numerous allusions to negative stereotypes placed upon women. The bound feet refers to an ancient Chinese custom of women's' feet being broken to appear small and dainty. Crippled brains refers to the fact that men were believed to be stereotypically smarter than women. Hair in curlers gives the image of a housewife doing the duties of a woman. And finally, the hands you love to touch are alluding to the stereotype of women being seen as sexual beings. Other lines that stereotype women include calling the trees (representing women) small and cozy and domestic and weak. The gardener symbolizes men suppressing women. These allusions and symbols make the poem everything it is. They add incredible meaning and without them the poem would be useless.


Overall, I enjoyed this poem. It sent a clear message without being too over the top. This poem was obviously inspired by the women's' movement for equality. For ages women have been considered to be inferior to men. Piercy's poem lashes out at this belief in inferiority. She does it with a sense of grace though. The analogy of the bonsai tree was a masterful creation. The effectiveness of the poem is greatly enhanced by the fact that Piercy is not writing a full out criticism against the treatment of women. She is not accusing, demanding, or ranting. Instead, she uses imagery to persuade the audience. I have never read such a tastefully done piece of literature that made such a statement.


Friday, March 28, 2008

A Portrait of the Artist As a Young Man

One of the most important symbols in the novel
was one of the characters herself; Emma. She is never really a main character, but is present from the beginning to the end and often on Stephen's mind. She is a symbol of purity and perfection; everything Stephen is not. Stephen sees Emma as an angelic creature, free of all sin and impurity. For much of the novel, Stephen places Emma up on this untouchable pedestal. She is above sin, above sex, and above him. It is not until chapter 5 that Stephen begins to rationalize his image of Emma. It first begins with the scene when he picks a louse off his neck, but crystallizes once he has a conversation with her at the university. Through talking with her, Stephen realizes that she is an ordinary individual, not the saint he imagined her as. She was still special to him, but no longer was above him. This transformation of Stephen's opinion regarding Emma symbolizes his struggle with religion. His religious extremism, from prostitutes to perfect piety, is portrayed by his realization Emma is not an angelic being. Stephen seeing her as an ordinary individual, instead of placing her on the pedestal is just like how he eventually sees a more middle of the road path with religion. He knows he does not want to live in continuous sin, but at the same time the life of perfect piety is no for him. He searches to find a balance with his religious life he finds it, just as he sees Emma for who she really is.


"Hell is a strait and dark and foul smelling prison, an abode of demons and lost souls, filled with fire and smoke. [...] There, by reason of the great number of the damned, the prisoners are heaped together in their awful prison, the walls of which are said to be four thousand miles thick: and the damned are so utterly bound and helpless [...] They lie in exterior darkness. For, remember, the fire of hell gives forth no light. [...] It is a never ending storm of darkness, dark flames and dark smoke of burning brimstone, amid which the bodies are heaped one upon another without even a glimpse of air. [...] The horror of this strait and dark prison is increased by its awful stench. All the filth of the world, all the offal and scum of the world, we are told, shall run there as to a vast reeking sewer when the terrible conflagration of the last day of purged the world. The brimstone too which burns there in such prodigious quantity fills all hell with its intolerable stench; and the bodies of the damned themselves exhale such a pestilential odour that as Saint Bonaventure says, one of them alone would suffice to infect the whole world." (128-129)

This extensive quote is only a small part of Father Arnall's powerful speech on hell and death. I choose this quote because this whole passage describing Father Arnall's description of hell is one of the most descriptive pieces of writing I have ever read. I know Stephen was greatly influenced by the speech, and I could relate to his reasons why. Nearly all the senses were touched in the description. It was difficult to even fathom the horror and terror the Stephen was being exposed to. Joyce's brilliance was extremely apparent in the way he was able to make his words touch the reader's senses. The exaggeration used was vastly effective in making the reader feel exactly what Stephen was feeling. The analogies Joyce uses to describe the smell and other senses are truly unbelievable. The descriptions drove the point home in a way that was nothing short of genius. I don't blame Stephen for being scared into confession. There is nothing worse that I can think of in this world than the horror of how Father Arnall's hell sounds. Hell is always described as a wretched place, but no description can come close to this one. Reading it was quite an experience.


When I read Invisible Man, I thought that was the most complex novel of the year. Well, there is a new novel that can claim that title now. Like Invisible Man, many messages and hidden meanings can be discovered by close reading of Portrait. I have never read a stream of consciousness in a novel of this length and complexity. I have mixed feelings towards it. At times, it was so confusing and complex that it seemed to in-depth. I almost felt as if I was reading Hawthorne; it was like I know Joyce was trying to say something, but felt that I had to wade through paragraphs to figure out what it meant. I also had trouble deriving what everything was supposed to mean on my own. Once we discussed things, they made sense and I could see what the symbols meant and were supposed to represent. On the flip side though, the novel contained some of the most descriptive passages I have ever read. The ability for Joyce to make me feel what he felt was truly awe inspiring. It was great to read Joyce's recount of his own experience. He was able to superbly describe what he had felt. The detail of Stephen's life, which is really Joyce's life retold, shows the excellent use of stream of consciousness. Overall, I enjoyed the novel because of the writing ability of Joyce. There may have been complex parts, but the insight Joyce gives into Stephen's mind made for a fantastic novel.

Friday, March 21, 2008

Poem 200-"Woman Work"


In the poem, Woman Work, the speaker is the author of the poem. The author, Maya Angelou, is writing about her situation in life. Angelou is a very famous writer who was actively involved in the Civil Rights Movement. Knowing this, the poem she writes takes on a much greater meaning than when read as if it was just about a housewife (not that a housewife doesn't have difficulties too). The speaker in the poem has all this responsibility to care for the children, the house, and the garden. Knowing the speaker is the author, the reader realizes that she is doing all of this in the face of extreme diversity. When I first read the poem I thought it may have been about a slave (yes, I know you are shocked Mr. Klimas). Upon doing research about the author it gave me a clearer picture that she was not a slave of early America, but still a captive of conservative times. The rhyme scheme and meter also add value to the poem. The poem utilizes an AABB rhyming pattern in the first stanza (tend-mend, mop-shop). The pattern of the pairs of lines and the flow that is created as a result give the poem a very measured effect. This represents the daily pattern of the speaker's life. Each day, they go from one task to the next without a rest. When the patterned, rhyming part of the poem changes after the first stanza so does the attitude of the speaker. Instead of discussing the work she must do, she is able to take a moment for herself and wish for help; just a small break in the routine to give her strength to continue on.


One literary device that adds a great deal to the poem is the use of interruption between the first stanza and the rest of the poem. There is an extremely apparent shift between the tone and message the author is sending. As discussed earlier, the first stanza is measured and patterned. Stanzas 2-5 are quite different. They are all four lines long and lack an obvious rhyme scheme. Though these four stanzas are similar with each other, they differ from the first stanza. The first stanza is all about what has to be done and what the speaker does regularly. When the interruption occurs, the speaker's thoughts shift to selfish ones. This sounds bad because being selfish is stereotyped as being bad. However, everyone needs sometime to themselves where they can just wish for the best. There is no crime in that. The four stanzas contain the thoughts about what the speaker yearns for. She wants to feel relief from her work and responsibility, she wants to be calm and relaxed, and most of all she wants all of her work to result in something. The last stanza of the poem is the most important part. It says, "Sun, rain, curving sky/Mountain, oceans, leaf and stone/Star shine, moon glow/You're all that I can call my own." (26-30). This line portrays another literary device in the poem-irony. How can things such as the sun, rain, and moon belong to one person? I thought they were there for everyone? The irony of the speaker believing these vast objects are the only thing she owns reveals the hardship of the situation she is in. She does all the work mentioned in the first stanza, but it does not appear to reap any benefit or reward that she can wrap her arms around. Even though, the sun, moon, and stars are not her personal possessions, she can call them her own because they represent her freedom and hope. She may work long hours, doing laborous work, but she can always recede to the comfort of the vast sky and its possessions and know that at least she is able to work for a better living.


I really enjoyed reading this poem. It sounded so personal and heartfelt that it was like Angelou was telling me her story in person. In the second stanza it says, "Shine on me, sunshine/Rain on me, rain" (15-16). By saying me, Angelou personalizes the story and the actions she asks for. Telling the sun to shine on and the rain to rain on a specific individual is a high demand. It appears that the speaker is asking for alot, but the speaker just wants to have some of the simple joys of life. I sensed that it was such a heartfelt request from a working mother that it was touching. I liked the structure of the first stanza with the short phrases that gave me a sense the speaker was frustrated from working so hard with little reward. I thought Angelou did a fantastic job at putting me in her shoes. I could feel her tiredness and sense her wishes. Angelou is obvious a very gifted writer because of these abilities to make her audience feel what she is saying.

Thursday, January 24, 2008

Invisible Man


Well, this was definitely the longest book I have read in awhile. Sometimes quantity does not mean quality because if the author cannot keeps the readers interest over many, many pages, then often the book does not get finished. Ralph Ellison, however, is able to carry the reader's interest over a lengthy novel in Invisible Man. I was unsure how to feel about the novel at first because it seemed a tad dry and boring. Once the narrator got situated in New York and his life got moving, so did the novel. Ellison writes one of the most intricate novels I have ever read. If you think about how much time it must have taken him to think of all the subtilties and hidden meanings you may find your mouth agape in pure amazement. The quality of the novel goes beyond impressive and straight to genius. He approaches the theme of racism and equality in a very different way than many writers who wrote about similar topics. We discussed many times how he could have just written about a problematic, black boy from the South who goes North to find himself. Ellison's style of how he takes on the race issue was intriguing and much more interesting to read. The only drawback I saw to the novel was that it was almost too good. It got to the point where almost every other line could be broken down to reveal some hidden meaning or symbolization of something. When the literature gets that detailed, some of the fun of reading is taken away because you get too focused on what is trying to be said by a seemingly insignificant statement. The internal struggles of the narrator though fascinated me. His character development was fantastic. The novel always kept you intrigued because it would leave you hanging with things. For example, the nameless narrator. I know whenever I was reading I kept wondering if I was going to find out the name of the narrator. Just this simple aspect of the novel was one of the many things that kept my interest throughout the novel. All in all, I envy Ellison's creative ability and intellect.
"Well, I was and yet I was invisible, that was the fundamental contradiction. I was and yet I was unseen. It was frightening and as I sat there I sensed another frightening world of possibilities. For now I saw that I could agree with Jack without agreeing. And I could tell Harlem to have hope when there was no hope. Perhaps I could tell them to hope until I found the basis of something real, some firm ground for action that would lead them onto the plane of history. But until then I would have to move them without myself being moved...I'd have to do a Rinehart." (Ellison 507)
This quote deals with the narrator's transition towards invisibility and his optimism before he is completely invisible. He feels that on some levels, others do not see him. At the same time, however, he still believes he can make a difference and have an effect on people. The narrator still has an attitude of trying to make his view of the Brotherhood movement work. He still wants to help the people of Harlem, even if he thinks he is not seen by people like Jack. The narrator is searching for a firm basis that can give the people of Harlem hope, but I think he is really looking for solid ground for himself to stand on and give himself hope. I actually think that by trying to act like Rinehart he will only disconnect himself more. He says that he cannot get emotionally moved, but in order to gain back some visibility he needs to be fully involved. Rinehart may appear to be well connected with everyone, but there is probably a great deal of distance between himself and other. Putting space between himself and others is not going to help the narrator become any less invisible. This quote is contradictory, which makes it very interesting. It is good because it shows the narrator still has hope and has not admitted defeat yet. He believes he still has a chance to make a difference. I enjoyed seeing the narrator when he still possessed this optimistic attitude where he did not care if he was invisible or not; he was still going to try to make a difference.
I found the scene involving Liberty Paints to be one of the most important in the novel. Many themes and motifs are portrayed in the scene, especially the blatant black and white motif, which is present throughout the novel. It is so ironic that the white paint is made from a black foundation. This fact is so symbolic of the reality of past American culture. The early American economy was based upon slave labor. Without it, the United States would most likely have crumbled in its infancy. This is just like the paint; without the black base, the pure white cannot be made. There cannot be white without black. The Liberty Paint company uses the word liberty to appear to represent American ideals. However, there is really not any liberty for some of its own employees. For example, Brockway does a large amount of work, but is not rewarded the way white employees who work far less are. He takes part in making a paint that is used to cover up any stain or mark. White covering black. There is not really anything more that could symbolized American society of this time period. The white supremacy was rampant as it attempted to swallow the black culture. It is important that this was the first place the narrator went to work. Just how the paint covers things, this is when he first started being covered with the result of him being invisible.

The Heart of Darkness




This book, as I am sure most people would agree to, was definitely a little out of the norm of my reading experiences. I am always open to new things, but I can definitely say that I was not really a fan of Heart of Darkness. The style it was written in, including dialect, syntax, and tone made the novel very difficult to understand and really get into. I find it difficult to really grasp the point of a novel when I cannot get interested in reading it. At times it appeared to be very dense like novels of Scarlet Letter proportion. Despite these superficial difficulties, Conrad creates extremely complex, interesting characters. Kurtz and Marlow are far from simple. Kurtz portrays the consumption of a man by evil. I could not wrap my mind around Kurtz because I cannot fathom the evil that overtook him. The darkness that surrounded the novel as a whole, surrounded him as an individual specifically. What horror he must really have dealt with. Marlow on the other hand, I really liked as a character. He struggled against his inner evil, but came out for the most part on top. He did not succumb to the evil like Kurtz. He felt it; he experienced it, but he did not let go of the wheel and lose control. While Conrad's created extremely appealing characters, he put them in a context that made it difficult to enjoy them to the full extent.




"She had [...] bizarre things, charms, gifts of witch-men, that hung about her, glittered and trembled at every step. She must have had the value of several elephant tusks upon her. She was savage and superb, wild-eyed and magnificent; there was something ominous and stately in her deliberate progress." (Conrad 142)
This quote is full of contradictions; much like the entire story. The quote describes the woman as "savage and superb" and "ominous and stately", which are odd sets of words to use to describe the same individual. The ideas the words represent just do not go together. This is just like Kurtz and the colonies. So many people rant of Kurtz's intelligence and skill, yet spears with heads on top line the outside of his hut. What kind of brilliant man can represent such savagery at the same time? It is the same with the colonies. The settlements on the coast misrepresent the whole picture to the mother countries in Europe. They see their colonies as only being like the coast settlements, not the interior where the heart of darkness lies. The primitive ruthlessness of the interior of the colony contradicts the pretty picture in the minds of the imperialistic countries in Europe. The quote shows that many things can have two very different sides to them. This woman may be intriguing, but walks with an aire of danger about her. Kurtz may be one of the greatest assets to the company's ivory collection, but he is also a savage murderer. The colonies may be a great economic asset for the European countries, but they are also the sites of unmentionable horrors. Conrad uses contradiction throughout the novel to contrast superficiality with reality.
One of the themes I found interesting in the novel was the contradiction of the interior vs. the exterior. The interior was referred to as the inner jungle where the heart of darkness lies that Marlow must travel into, while the coast is viewed in a much more favorable light. The joy of the exterior and the horror of the interior are supposed to be symbolic of human nature. The novel delves into the question of whether or not evil lies within everyone. All signs from the novel seem to point to yes it does. To use Kurtz as an example, he appeared successful and intelligent on the outside. The leaders of the company saw him as a man of great talent in acquiring great amounts of ivory. However, as Marlow tragically witnesses, Kurtz was far from this fine man other saw him as. Marlow saw what lay in the interior of Kurtz-pure evil. Even calling the interior the heart of darkness is symbolic of the interior of everyone of us. Your heart is in the interior, and with that is also darkness. Many people have such thick, bright exteriors that it is sometimes difficult for the evil interior to pierce through the light. A lot of times the interior will attempt to cover up for what is on the inside. Throughout the novel interiors and exteriors are tied together by contradiction. At first sight things appear one way to Marlow, but upon further examination, end up being quite the opposite of his original thoughts.

Thursday, December 13, 2007

Player Piano

I THINK THE PICTURE SPEAKS FOR ITSELF ABOUT THE NOVEL


"Call yourself a doctor, too, do you? said Mr. Haycox.

"I think I can say without fear of contradiction that I earned that degree," said Doctor Pond cooly. "My thesis was the third longest in any field in the country that year--eight hundred and ninety-six pages, double-spaced, with narrow margins."


"Real-estate salesman," said Mr. Haycox. He looked back and forth between Paul and Doctor Pond, waiting for them to say something worth his attention. When they'd failed to rally after twenty seconds, he turned to go. "I'm doctor of cowshit, pigshit, and chickenshit," he said. "When you doctors figure out what you want, you'll find me out in the barn shoveling my thesis."


This is one of the most humorous passage in the novel. The straight-shooter, Mr. Haycox, boldly insults not only the two doctors, but their society itself. The average worker points out the ridiculousness of so many professions where the title of doctor is given to the people who work in that field. Mr. Haycox thinks the title is just a self esteem booster for the men because in his eyes only dentists, vets, and physicians are acutally doctors. But in this society, just because a man writes an 800-some page document, he gets to put DR. in front of his name. The humor of Mr. Haycox's thesis was just a slap in the face to the doctors. He jokes that if their professions can give them the title of doctor, then why not his. His thesis however, is real work, not just a fabricated sucking up in the form of words on a 896 page paper. I love how the person doing the ridiculing in this passage is the one that the doctors look down upon. Mr. Haycox may not be Dr. Haycox, but it is definitely apparent that he is the one with the intelligence to know how messed up their society is.



Betrayal is a central theme in the novel. One of the most prevalent examples of betrayal is soceity's betrayal of itself. The society in the novel continued to pursue technology to the extent that it eliminated much of the need for the talents and skills of real people. People began replacing themselves with machines, and for the most part just stood by and watched it happen. I find it completely ridiculous that even after they destroy Illium, there are people rummaging through the wreckage to see if there is anything they could use to build what else?--MORE MACHINES!!! How does that make any sense? With a mentality like this, there is no one to blame for the betrayal of society except for society itself. Bud Calhoun provides an example of the self-inflicted betrayal when he creates a machine that can do his own job. Is technology and the pursuit of expanding it that tempting that common sense to know when enough is enough is ignored? However ironic this may seem, it is very typical of human culture to shoot themselves in the foot and then complain about it. And once the complaints cause action, it only results in the same thing happening again. Look at war in our culture. When there is a war going on everyone complains about the death and destruction, but there is almost always a war going on somewhere in the world. Maybe human curiosity and interest just cannot be taught a lesson...


Player Piano had to be my favorite novel we have read thus far this year. It seemed to be quite unique from all the other mechanized society novels we read. I felt like Vonnegut created themes and symbols that were easier to understand and relate to. The society in the novel was perhaps one of the most believable of all the novels we have read. There is such a push for technology advancements and automated this, automated that in our society that even now, machines are doing the jobs humans once did. Most of them still need humans to operate them, but how long will it be before our society looks unnervingly similar to Illium? I also liked Player Piano because a large group revolted against the norm in chaos. In the other novels, it was really only one or two characters who tried to overthrow the powers in control. Even in We, when the one group tried to take over the INTEGRAL, there was not much action. The revolt in this novel, however, was full of destruction and showed the rebellious group coming so close to success. In the novel, I also found Paul's journey of understanding what is important to him and what he truly values, quite interesting to follow. Many people criticize Paul for not acting fast enough or for not really being that strong. I found that Paul was just in a difficult situation and it just took him some time to see the light. I don't believe he let Anita control him; he just was trying to grasp for any chance that they may have actually shared true love. Anita's selfishness and ignorance was so great that it was amusing to read. All she worried about was the fame that would come with being the wife of an important engineer. In my eyes, she was such a weak, distasteful character. The relationship between Paul and Anita was a direct shot by Vonnegut at marriages in our society. So many people get married for the wrong reason, and end up not really being in true love with their spouse. Vonnegut is trying to show how mechanical some marriages are even in real life. Whenever author's take shots at big issues in our society through their characters in their novels, I find it very entertaining. One last thing I enjoyed was Vonnegut's style. I loved the way he used satiric and ironic humor to prove his points. Overall, I really liked Player Paino.

Thursday, November 8, 2007

We




I found the relationship between D-503 and I-330 to be one of the most interesting topics in the novel. In what I consider a tragedy, D-503 suffers greatly at the hands of I-330. She uses tactics such as lust, daring, and disattachment (yes I may have just made up that word) to keep pulling D-503 in closer, but to keep him far enough away to not interfere at the same time. It is clear that D-503 falls in some sort of one-sided loving relationship with I-330. He puts himself through much of the tortute he endures because he cannot get her out of his head. He appears to hate her, yet love her endlessly all at the same time. These mixed up feelings confuse D-503 so much that he nears the point of insanity. He goes against OneState and pushes O-90 away all because he is blind to anyone or anything, but I-330. The irony and tragic humor is that I-330 does not feel this way at all towards poor D-503. The only thing she is really putting into the relationship is the occasional pink ticket to satisfy D-503 just enough until the next time. I-330 leads D-503 on regarding many different issues from how she feels towards him to her interest in the Integral. The key is, though, that her interest in D-503 is the Integral. Without the ship, D-503 is worthless to her. When I-330's plans to capture the Integral are foiled, she turns on D-503 and brings his world crashing down around him. Everything comes full circle for him as he finally understands and believes the truth that I-330 was only using her sex appeal to make him a puppet of hers to use for her purpose. The shock and devastation numb D-503 out of existance basically. With how terrible D-503 felt on the inside, it was probably better for him to finally undergo the Benefactor's surgery.



"You didn't really go to the Bureau of Guardians, did you?'
'I was. . . I couldn't. I was sick.'
'Yes. Well, it's about what I expected--something was bound to stop you, no matter what [sharp teeth, smile]. But now you are. . . in my hands.'" (Zamyatin 53)


Talk about a weak-willed character. This scence occurred early on in the relationship between D-503 and I-330. They had not even spent much time together, let alone had he had time to figure out what his feelings were. At this point, it was pure seductiveness that prevented D-503 from reporting I-330's transgression. Zamyatin adds the descriptive brackets to prove the reason why D-503 did not report her. [Sharp teeth, smile] supports the idea that this early in the novel, D-503 was still purely entranced by the physical aspect of I-330. This scene foreshadowed numerous scences where D-503's weakness (or love for I-330; does not matter how you say it because in this case they are synonomous with each other) is exploited.


I thought Yevgeny Zamyatin did a phenomenal job at writing this novel. I was impressed with it from cover to cover. His character development was fantastic. The way he built up the tragic relationship between D-503 and I-330, only to bring it crashing down all at once at the end for both of them was a unique characteristic, which is absent from many novels. The use of syntax is extremely prevalent throughout the novel. D-503's confused, random thoughts, his unfocused thought processes, and incomplete ideas and thoughts contribute to the excellent overall portrayal of his character. The scheduling aspect of the lives of the characters in the novel was not a far-fetched idea. We are all on so many defined schedules already, that it is not difficult to imagine a society like OneState in terms of scheduling at all. Overall I enjoyed reading the work.

Wednesday, November 7, 2007

Anthem


One of the most prevalent themes/ideas in the novel was the value of the individual and their individuality. Equality rises against everything he is told by the people running the society. He is supposed to be doing his job and his job only. Equality is taught to not meddle in other areas of life because he has one purpose-to work for the good of the whole. It is not important for Equality to be individually satisfied as long as the whole society is functioning properly. Equality is such a likeable character because he rebels agaisnt this collectiveness. He is different though from the stereotypical, problematic rebellious character. He does not go about raising an army to overthrow the government or igniting the fire in other peoples' souls with invigorating speeches; he simply thinks for himself. He realizes that he can accomplish and ponder on his own, without the help of his brothers. He realizes that there is not so much we as there is I.



"The word 'We' is as lime poured over men, which sets and hardens to stone, and crushes all beneath it, and that which is white and that which is black are lost equally in the grey of it. It is the word by which the depraved steal the virtue of the good, by which the weak steal the might of the strong, by which the fools steal the wisdom of the sages. What if my joy if all hand, even the unclean, can reach into it? What is my wisdom, if even the fools can dictate to me? What is my freedom, if all creatures, even the botched and the impotent, are my masters? What is my life, if I am but to bow, to agree and to obey? But I am done with this creed of corruption. I am dont with the monster of 'We', the word of serfdom, of plunder, of misery, falsehood, and shame. And now I see the face of god, and I raise this god over the earth, this god whom men have sought since men came into being, this god who will grant them joy and peace and pride. This god, this one word: 'I'" (Rand 97).


Wow, that was a long quote, but nonetheless quite a useful one. It is so important because it shows Equality coming to a realization of the power of I. He finds it so powerful that he compares the word I being a god. To place this individuality on such a high pedestal, proves just how much he was isolated from the idea of himself. He was taught to love We, but in this quote, Equality is cursing We. He sees the word with a negative attitude. Equality resents ever being associated with the dirty, foolish word. The light shed on his situation by his discovery of light sends a direct beam of bright, focused light right onto the letter I.
Out of the four books we have read, Anthem, was probably my least favorite. I never really got a chance to throw myself into it because it went so fast. It was like a two-night read. We did not have much discussion on it and I thought the plot was pretty simplistic. There was perfect order to the plot with each thing getting resolved before the next section began. Despite these critiques I did enjoy the themes Ayn Rand presented in the novel, especially individuality. I love everything about individuality. It was great to read how she created a society without, but also created a main character to retrieve what was lost and regain back his individuality.